Books submitted must meet the following criteria:
The book must be available in paperback by December 1, 2026.
We cannot have read the book within the last 5 years. See the book list PDF on our Facebook Group or look on this website under Reading Lists/Past Reading Lists.
It must be clearly and primarily classified as mystery fiction (no sci/fi, true crime, literary fiction with “mysterious happenings,” etc.) This can be difficult to tell sometimes. Read samples. Read reviews. If you use AI, try typing something like, “is this book primarily mystery fiction or can it be better classified under another genre?”
Young Adult mystery fiction is allowed
Multiple books by one author may be nominated but only the one with the highest rank gets in, the others disqualified. Same rule applies to YA books.
If a book was proposed last year and not chosen, it may be resubmitted for consideration
How to submit a book:
Send your submissions to Marni.
You can use the link from my Meetup profile or email me directly at malka1966@gmail.com
Please use the following format: Title, Author First Name Author Last Name
Include a 2-4 sentence “blurb” about why you are nominating this book.
Please do not copy/paste from the back of the book or from other websites. We want your personal thoughts!
Here is a sample nomination:
Drowning With Others, Linda Keir
This book has all the things I love-a cold case, secrets from long ago, tricky family dynamics and a great title.
Your submission will be reviewed
After books are submitted, I will check to make sure all the criteria are met. If I have questions I will contact you. Once your nomination has been approved it will be posted on this website.
Review other members’ submissions
Remember to check back frequently during October as I’ll be adding new books throughout Oct. 1-31.
Deadline for all submissions: October 31.